I know this comes up but I haven't found a thread with recent enough information to be useful.
Location-based dating works very differently depending on where you actually are. The mainstream app advice that works in New York or LA produces very different results in a mid-size city or rural area. I'm trying to find advice that's calibrated to actual geographic reality rather than assuming everyone is in a major metro.
Rural users consistently report better results from mainstream apps than from niche ones because of pool size.
Would really value hearing from people with genuine experience rather than just what the platforms claim about themselves.