Long-time lurker with a first proper question about makes a good dating profile.
Where makes a good dating profile is concerned, One thing I did not expect was that the bulk of the matches that stuck never got past small talk. The useful filter turned out to be replies that reference what you wrote, not the feature list, especially where profile quality is concerned. What I care about most with makes a good is what actually makes a profile land.
What was your sample size on profile quality? Anything you have on profile quality is useful, positive or not.
Draw your own conclusions about makes a good dating profile from that.